Baby It’s Code Outside – How to Make Sure AI is on Your Talent Strategy Nice List  

December 16, 2025

Matt Gainsford

Matt Gainsford

AI can move fast, but it can’t hire well on its own. This holiday-themed blog explores how to use AI in your talent strategy without losing what matters most: human judgment, empathy, and connection.

Estimated Read Time: 7-8 Minutes

pexels-tara-winstead-8386440-8

The snow is falling, the cocoa is hot, and somewhere in the cloud, AI is sorting resumes faster than Santa’s elves on a caffeine-fueled mix of cookies, hot chocolate, and espresso. But here’s the cold, Scrooge-sized truth: Santa isn’t real, the elves aren’t real… and neither is a magical algorithm that will “sleigh” your hiring problems by itself (this was a hardtype—we’re sorry). 

AI is powerful, and it’ll only get stronger. It can sift through hundreds of resumes, spot patterns, and even predict candidate fit. But without judgment, empathy, and human connection, it’s just a fancy sorting machine, like a robotic Grinch in a cubicle or a fruitcake nobody asked for. 

This holiday season, let’s make sure your AI lands on the Nice List while keeping humans at the center. After all, High Tech needs a Human Touch. 

Why AI is Here to Sleigh 

AI isn’t a passing snowflake; it’s here to stay. It’s embedded in sourcing, screening, candidate engagement, and onboarding. It’s fast, efficient, and yes, it can make your talent strategy feel like magic. 

But here’s the frosty reality: efficiency without empathy is like wrapping a gift in newspaper; technically, functional, but nobody’s impressed. Candidates notice when they’re treated like data points instead of people. Algorithms don’t hand out warm smiles, personalized emails, or thoughtful follow-ups after interviews. Humans do. 

The savviest talent leaders know this: AI can help scale your process, but humans deliver the sparkle. 

The Nice List – High Tech That Sparkles 

When AI earns a spot on your Nice List, it’s enhancing human judgment, not replacing it: 

  • Fairness & Bias Mitigation: Audit regularly. No coal-filled sleigh rides allowed. 
  • Transparent Communication: Candidates deserve clarity. AI should inform, not ghost. You can schedule follow-up texts/emails to keep candidates informed, but any big news needs to be shared by a person.  

If you’ve ever seen Futurama (or enjoy niche jokes), you’ll get the following… 

  • Data Privacy & Security: Treat candidate info like it’s the last gift under the tree; this one’s special, fragile, and needs to be treated with utmost care. 
  • Alignment with Employer Brand: AI should reinforce your story, not undermine it. Those boilerplate templates are like the impersonal Christmas cards your local car dealership sends out because you once passed a sideways glance at a shiny new minivan online, and well, now they’ve got you and want to show you how much they care about you….’re business. 
  • Sourcing, Summarizing, and Synthesizing: AI sifts through complex candidate databases, executing precise Boolean searches to uncover the most aligned candidates (on paper). It can be a game-changerwhen collating and analyzing technical data from resumes, assessments, and interviews, delivering a clear, actionable synopsis for smarter hiring decisions, which are made by a person. 

A “Nice List” AI is like a well-trained elf: efficient, helpful, and charming; without stealing the spotlight. 

The Naughty List – When AI’s a Grinch 

Not all AI deserves cookies and milk. Some deserve coal: 

  • Over-Automation: When AI handles everything, candidates feel trapped in a bot blizzard in need of nuance in the form of a bright red nose to lead them out. 
  • Ignoring Bias: Algorithms learning from biased data is like letting the office Grinch run HR.  
  • Generic Messaging: Boilerplate emails scream, “You’re just a number.” 
  • No Human Oversight: AI making final decisions alone is like sending a snowman to negotiate a raise in summer. 

If your AI is on the Naughty List, it’s time to unwrap some human holiday magic

High Tech, Human Touch – The Perfect Gift 

The best talent strategy doesn’t rely on AI or humans alone. It relies on the intersection of both

  • Audit and Adjust: Regularly review AI tools for bias, errors, and misfires. 
  • Keep Humans in the Loop: Automation is a helper, not a decision-maker. It’s like guessing what people want for Christmas, just ask Aunt Maeve, who still buys you 101 Dalmatian Pajamas… I’m 45, Maeve FORTY-FIVE, and it’s actually Gryffindor, if you have to ask. 
  • Personalize Communications: Use AI to free up time so humans can add the sparkle. After all, it’s the people who make it meaningful. 
  • Balance Efficiency With Experience: Streamline, but never frost over respect, warmth, or empathy.  

High Tech, Human Touch isn’t just a sentiment; it’s a strategy. AI can enhance decisions, but the human connection is the star on top. 

Wrap-Up: Hire With Heart, Head, and Briefcase 

At Titus, we hire with heart (head, and briefcase). AI can help, but putting the right person in the right seat is a responsibility that requires judgment, empathy, and care.  

Before we’d help even a Scrooge-level hiring manager, we’d want to see a workplace with a strong Employer Value Proposition; one we’d feel confident sharing with candidates.  

High Tech, Human Touch means using AI wisely while ensuring your process reflects your principles. It’s about being thoughtful, intentional, and accountable, because the right hire in the wrong culture isn’t a gift; it’s a lump of coal in the water cooler, instead of the fire. 

This holiday season, make AI your helpful elf, keep humans at the center, and hire in a way that’s responsible, human, and impactful. That’s the kind of “Nice List” we like to be on, and the kind of workplace your top talent deserves. 

High Tech, Human Touch: check your list twice. AI on the Nice List; that’s real holiday magic. 

Let's Start a Conversation